#!/usr/bin/env python """ Scyther : An automatic verifier for security protocols. Copyright (C) 2007-2013 Cas Cremers This program is free software; you can redistribute it and/or modify it under the terms of the GNU General Public License as published by the Free Software Foundation; either version 2 of the License, or (at your option) any later version. This program is distributed in the hope that it will be useful, but WITHOUT ANY WARRANTY; without even the implied warranty of MERCHANTABILITY or FITNESS FOR A PARTICULAR PURPOSE. See the GNU General Public License for more details. You should have received a copy of the GNU General Public License along with this program; if not, write to the Free Software Foundation, Inc., 51 Franklin Street, Fifth Floor, Boston, MA 02110-1301, USA. """ """ Example script to show how to perform large-scale tests using the Scyther Python API (contained in the Scyther subdirectory) In this example, multi-protocol attack analysis is performed on a small test set. Author: Cas Cremers """ from Scyther import Scyther from optparse import OptionParser, OptionGroup, SUPPRESS_HELP import time import os.path import json try: from progressbar import * PROGRESSBAR = True except ImportError: from progressbarDummy import * PROGRESSBAR = False print(""" Missing the progressbar library. It can be downloaded from: http://code.google.com/p/python-progressbar/ """) FOUND = [] ALLMPA = [] ALLCLAIMS = [] INVOLVED = [] PROTFILETONAME = {} PROTNAMETOFILE = {} OPTS = None ARGS = None PICKLEDATA = set() #--------------------------------------------------------------------------- def parseArgs(): usage = "usage: %prog [options] [inputfile]" description = "test-mpa.py is a test script to help with multi-protocol analysis." parser = OptionParser(usage=usage,description=description, version="%prog 2.0") group = OptionGroup(parser, "Bounding the search space") group.add_option("-m","--max-protocols",type="int",dest="maxprotocols",default=3, help="Define maximum number of protocols in a multi-protocol attack [3].") group.add_option("-r","--max-runs",type="int",dest="maxruns",default=4, help="Define maximum number of runs in the analysis [4].") group.add_option("-T","--timeout",type="int",dest="timeout",default=600, help="Timeout in seconds for each analysis [600].") group.add_option("-L","--limit",type="int",dest="limit",default=0, help="Limit the length of the list of protocols [None].") parser.add_option_group(group) group = OptionGroup(parser, "Matching type options") group.add_option("-t","--typed",dest="defoptarray",default=[],action="append_const",const="--match=0", help="Verify protocols with respect to a typed model (-m 0) [default]") group.add_option("-b","--basic-types",dest="defoptarray",default=[],action="append_const",const="--match=1", help="Verify protocols with respect to basic type flaws only (-m 1)") group.add_option("-u","--untyped",dest="defoptarray",default=[],action="append_const",const="--match=2", help="Verify protocols with respect to an untyped model (-m 2)") group.add_option("-A","--all-types",dest="alltypes",default=False,action="store_true", help="Verify protocols with respect to all matching types") parser.add_option_group(group) group = OptionGroup(parser, "Restricting self-communication") group.add_option("-U","--init-unique",dest="defoptarray",default=[],action="append_const",const="--init-unique", help="Use Scythers --init-unique switch to filter out initiators talking to themselves.") group.add_option("-E","--extravert",dest="defoptarray",default=[],action="append_const",const="--extravert", help="Use Scythers --extravert switch to filter out agents talking to themselves.") group.add_option("","--self-communication",dest="selfcommunication",default=False,action="store_true", help="Explore all self-communication restrictions (as MPA-only option).") parser.add_option_group(group) # Misc parser.add_option("","--pickle",dest="pickle", help="Do not invoke Scyther but write intended calls to a file with the given name.") # action="store" and type="string" are defaults parser.add_option("-l","--latex",dest="latex", help="Output latex files with the given prefix.") # action="store" and type="string" are defaults parser.add_option("-v","--verbose",dest="verbose",default=False,action="store_true", help="Be more verbose.") parser.add_option("-D","--debug",dest="debug",default=False,action="store_true", help="Enable debugging features.") parser.add_option("-p","--plain",dest="plain",default=False,action="store_true", help="Ensure plain output, e.g., no progress bars.") return parser.parse_args() #--------------------------------------------------------------------------- class Attack(object): def __init__(self,claim,mpalist): self.claim = claim self.mpalist = mpalist def protocol(self): return self.claim.protocol def mpashort(self): s = [] for fn in self.mpalist: ptn = os.path.normpath(fn) (head,tail) = os.path.split(ptn) s.append(tail) return s def claimid(self): return "%s" % (self.claim.id) def __str__(self): s = "(%s,%s)" % (self.claim.id, self.mpashort()) return s def fullstr(self): s = "%s,%s" % (self.claim.id, self.mpalist) return s def __cmp__(self,other): s1 = self.fullstr() s2 = other.fullstr() if (s1 == s2): return 0 else: if s1 < s2: return -1 else: return 1 #--------------------------------------------------------------------------- def uniq(l): ll = [] for x in l: if x not in ll: ll.append(x) return ll def powerset(s): """ s is a set returns the powerset """ pws = set([frozenset()]) for el in s: # Double old powerset by adding its elements and also new ones for s2 in pws.copy(): if len(s2) == 0: pws.add(frozenset([el])) else: pws.add(frozenset([el]).union(s2)) return pws #--------------------------------------------------------------------------- def MyScyther(protocollist,filt=None,options=[],checkpickle=True): """ Evaluate the composition of the protocols in protocollist. If there is a filter, i.e. "ns3,I1" then only this specific claim will be evaluated. By default, when Pickling, no evaluation is done (checkpickle=True). Setting 'checkpickle' to False ignores this check and verifies anyway. """ global OPTS global PICKLEDATA s = Scyther.Scyther() # Standard opts = OPTS.defoptarray + options # Cover for caching issue where no --match= option is given (default to 0) matchfound = False for opt in opts: if opt.startswith("--match="): matchfound = True break if not matchfound: opts.append("--match=0") # Adding other command-line parameters (i.e. with arguments) opts.append("-T %i" % (int(OPTS.timeout))) opts.append("--max-runs=%i" % (int(OPTS.maxruns))) # arguments to call s.options = (" ".join(sorted(uniq(opts)))).strip() if OPTS.debug: print(s.options) for protocol in sorted(protocollist): s.addFile(protocol) if checkpickle and OPTS.pickle: # Do not really verify! Just dump request if not already known if s.verifyOne(filt, checkKnown=True) == False: PICKLEDATA.add((tuple(sorted(protocollist)),s.options,filt)) else: # Verify results s.verifyOne(filt) return s def getCorrectIsolatedClaims(protocolset,options=[]): """ Given a set of protocols, determine the correct claims when run in isolation. Returns a tuple, consisting of - a list of compiling protocols - a list of tuples (protocol,claimid) wich denote correct claims """ correctclaims = [] goodprotocols = [] if not OPTS.plain: widgets = ['Scanning for claims that are correct in isolation: ', SimpleProgress(), ' protocols (', Percentage(), ') ', Bar(marker='#',left='[',right=']') ] pbar = ProgressBar(widgets=widgets, maxval=len(protocolset)) pbar.start() count = 0 cpcount = 0 for protocol in protocolset: # verify protocol in isolation s = MyScyther([protocol],options=options,checkpickle=False) # investigate the results goodprotocols.append(protocol) allfalse = True for claim in s.claims: global ALLCLAIMS global PROTFILETONAME global PROTNAMETOFILE if claim not in ALLCLAIMS: ALLCLAIMS.append(claim) if claim.okay: correctclaims.append((protocol,claim.id)) allfalse = False PROTFILETONAME[protocol] = str(claim.protocol) PROTNAMETOFILE[str(claim.protocol)] = protocol count += 1 if not allfalse: cpcount += 1 if not OPTS.plain: pbar.update(count) if not OPTS.plain: pbar.finish() return (goodprotocols,correctclaims,cpcount) def verifyProtList(protlist,claimid,options=[]): """ Check attacks on this protocol list. Returns True if no attack ("correct") and False if an attack is found. """ s = MyScyther(protlist,claimid,options) claim = s.getClaim(claimid) if claim: if not claim.okay: return False return True def verifyProtSubSet(protlist,claimid,options=[]): """ Check attacks on true subsets of this list. Note subsets must include the claim id """ global OPTS ps = powerset(set(protlist)) for s in ps: if (len(s) > 0) and (len(s) < len(protlist)): res = verifyProtList(list(s),claimid,options) if res == False: """ If an attack is found we're actually done but for pickle we make an exception to generate all possible variants. """ if not OPTS.pickle: return False return True def verifyMPAattack(mpalist,claimid,options=[]): """ Check for Multi-Protocol Attacks on this protocol list. Returns True if no attack ("correct") and False if an MPA attack is found. First consider subsets, so if there is an attack there, don't consider others. """ global OPTS res = verifyProtSubSet(mpalist,claimid,options) if res or OPTS.pickle: """ Only really needed when no attack found but for pickle we make an exception to generate all possible variants. """ return verifyProtList(mpalist,claimid,options) return True def verifyMPAlist(mpalist,claimid,options=[]): """ Check the existence of a multi-protocol attack in this context If an attack is found, we return False, otherwise True. This is needed for the iteration later. """ global OPTS, ARGS if OPTS.debug: print(time.asctime(), mpalist, claimid, options) if not verifyMPAattack(mpalist,claimid,options): global FOUND global ALLFOUND global INVOLVED claim = claimidToClaim(claimid) # This is an MPA attack! if OPTS.debug: print("I've found a multi-protocol attack on claim %s in the context %s." % (claimid,str(mpalist))) att = Attack(claim,mpalist) FOUND.append(att) ALLFOUND.append(att) inv = [claim.protocol] for fn in mpalist: global PROTFILETONAME inv.append(PROTFILETONAME[fn]) for pn in inv: if pn not in INVOLVED: INVOLVED.append(pn) #return False return True def constructMPAlist(protocolset,claimid,mpalist,length,start,callback,options=[]): """ Append a list of parallel protocols, without duplicates, such that the added part is lexicographically ordered (from index 'start' in the protocol list) For each possible list, the function callback is called. If the callback returns true, iteration proceeds (returning true in the end), otherwise it aborts and returns false. """ if len(mpalist) < length: # list is not long enough yet for pn in range(start,len(protocolset)): p = protocolset[pn] if p not in mpalist: if not constructMPAlist(protocolset,claimid,mpalist + [p],length,pn+1,callback,options=options): return False return True else: # list is long enough: callback return callback(mpalist,claimid,options) def findMPA(protocolset,protocol,claimid,options=[]): """ The protocol claim is assumed to be correct. When does it break? """ global OPTS # First we examine 2-protocol attacks, and then increase the # number of parallel protocols if we don't find any attacks on the # claim. maxcount = OPTS.maxprotocols count = 2 if len(protocolset) < maxcount: # we cannot have more protocols in parallel than there are # protocols. maxcount = len(protocolset) # the actual incremental search loop while count <= maxcount: constructMPAlist(protocolset,claimid,[protocol],count,0,verifyMPAlist,options) count += 1 return None def foundToDicts(attacklist = []): """ Turn a list of attacks into a more structured dict of dicts protocolname -> claimid -> P(attack) """ res = {} for att in attacklist: pn = str(att.protocol()) cl = att.claimid() if pn not in list(res.keys()): res[pn] = {} if cl not in list(res[pn].keys()): res[pn][cl] = set() res[pn][cl].add(att) return res def findAllMPA(protocolset,options=[],mpaoptions=[]): """ Given a set of protocols, find multi-protocol attacks """ global FOUND global OPTS, ARGS global PROTNAMETOFILE global ALLCLAIMS FOUND = [] # Find all correct claims in each protocol (protocolset,correct,cpcount) = getCorrectIsolatedClaims(protocolset,options) print("Investigating %i correct claims in %i protocols." % (len(correct), cpcount)) mpaprots = [] res = [] if len(correct) == 0: print("Nothing to do.") return res if OPTS.verbose: """ When verbose, list correct claims in protocols """ pmapclaims = {} for (protocol,claimid) in correct: if protocol not in list(pmapclaims.keys()): pmapclaims[protocol] = set() pmapclaims[protocol].add(claimid) print("Protocols with correct claims:") if len(list(pmapclaims.keys())) == 0: print(" None.") else: for pk in list(pmapclaims.keys()): print(" %s, %s" % (pk, pmapclaims[pk])) print() left = set() for p in protocolset: if p not in list(pmapclaims.keys()): left.add(p) print("Protocols with no correct claims:") if len(left) == 0: print(" None.") else: for p in left: print(" %s" % (p)) print() # output of all claims (only if latex required) if OPTS.latex: clset = set() for claim in ALLCLAIMS: prot = str(claim.protocol) file = PROTNAMETOFILE[prot] clid = claim.id descr = claim.roledescribe() tup = (file,prot,clid,descr) clset.add(tup) fp = open("gen-%s-claims.txt" % (OPTS.latex),"w") fp.write("%% OPTS: %s\n" % OPTS) fp.write("%% ARGS: %s\n" % ARGS) for (file,prot,clid,descr) in sorted(clset): fp.write("%s; %s; %s; %s\n" % (file,prot,clid,descr)) fp.close() # Latex output of protocols with correct claims if OPTS.latex: pmapclaims = {} for (protocol,claimid) in correct: if protocol not in list(pmapclaims.keys()): pmapclaims[protocol] = set() pmapclaims[protocol].add(claimid) fp = open("gen-%s-correctclaims.tex" % (OPTS.latex),"w") fp.write("%% OPTS: %s\n" % OPTS) fp.write("%% ARGS: %s\n" % ARGS) fp.write("\\begin{tabular}{ll}\n") fp.write("Protocol & Claims \\\\\n") for protocol in sorted(pmapclaims.keys()): fp.write("%s & " % (PROTFILETONAME[protocol])) claims = sorted(pmapclaims[protocol]) latexcl = set() for claimid in claims: claim = claimidToClaim(claimid) latexcl.add(claim.roledescribe()) fp.write("; ".join(sorted(latexcl))) fp.write("\\\\\n") fp.write("\\end{tabular}\n") fp.close() # For all these claims... if not OPTS.plain: widgets = ['Scanning for MPA attacks: ', SimpleProgress(), ' claims (', Percentage(), ') ', Bar(marker='#',left='[',right=']'), ETA() ] pbar = ProgressBar(widgets=widgets, maxval=len(correct)) pbar.start() count = 0 # Concatenate options but add space iff needed alloptions = options + mpaoptions for (protocol,claimid) in correct: # Try to find multi-protocol attacks findMPA(protocolset,protocol,claimid,options=alloptions) count += 1 if not OPTS.plain: pbar.update(count) if not OPTS.plain: pbar.finish() """ The below computation assumes protocol names are unique to files, but if they are not, some other errors should have been reported by the Scyther backend anyway (conflicting protocol definitions in MPA analysis). """ for att in FOUND: pn = att.protocol() if pn not in mpaprots: mpaprots.append(pn) res.append(att) """ Latex table of attacks TODO : map file names to protocol names, write out claim details TODO : remove main protocol from list (it's: "MPA attacks when run in parallel with") TODO : Check whether current tests stop after finding *one* MPA attack or whether they find *all*. """ if OPTS.latex and not OPTS.pickle: fp = open("gen-%s-mpaattacks.tex" % (OPTS.latex),"w") fp.write("%% OPTS: %s\n" % OPTS) fp.write("%% ARGS: %s\n" % ARGS) fp.write("\\begin{tabular}{lll}\n") fp.write("Protocol & Claim & MPA attacks \\\\ \n") # Convert to more useful structure (maybe move one level up) res = foundToDicts(FOUND) """ Scan per protocol in mpaprots (maybe sorted?) """ for prot in sorted(res.keys()): """ List claim and then attack scenarios (to some max?) """ ltprot = prot for claimid in sorted(res[prot].keys()): firstclaim = True for att in sorted(res[prot][claimid]): if firstclaim: ltclaim = att.claim.roledescribe() firstclaim = False attl = att.mpalist ltattacks = [] for attprot in attl: if PROTFILETONAME[attprot] != att.claim.protocol: ltattacks.append(PROTFILETONAME[attprot]) fp.write("%s & %s & %s \\\\ \n" % (ltprot,ltclaim,sorted(ltattacks))) # Erase for cleaner table ltprot = "" ltclaim = "" fp.write("\\end{tabular}\n") fp.close() print("-" * 70) print("Summary:") print() print("We scanned %i protocols with options [%s]." % (len(protocolset),options)) print("We found %i correct claims." % (len(correct))) print("We then scanned combinations of at most %i protocols with options [%s]." % (OPTS.maxprotocols,alloptions)) if OPTS.pickle: print("However, just precomputing now, hence we are not drawing any conclusions.") else: print("We found %i MPA attacks." % (len(FOUND))) print("The attacks involve the claims of %i protocols." % (len(mpaprots))) print("-" * 70) print() return res def claimidToClaim(claimid): """ Return claim object given a claim id """ global ALLCLAIMS for claim in ALLCLAIMS: if claim.id == claimid: return claim def showDiff(reslist): """ Show difference between (opts,mpaopts,attacklist) tuples in list """ if len(reslist) == 0: print("Comparison list is empty") return (opt1,mpaopt1,al1) = reslist[0] print("-" * 70) print("Base case: attacks for \n [%s]:" % (opt1 + mpaopt1)) print() print(len(al1)) for a in al1: print("Base attack: %s" % (a)) print("-" * 70) print() for i in range(0,len(reslist)-1): (opt1,mpaopt1,al1) = reslist[i] (opt2,mpaopt2,al2) = reslist[i+1] print("-" * 70) print("Comparing the attacks for \n [%s] with\n [%s]:" % (opt1 + mpaopt1, opt2 + mpaopt2)) print() print(len(al1), len(al2)) for a in al2: if a not in al1: print("Added attack: %s" % (a)) for a in al1: if a not in al2: print("Removed attack: %s" % (a)) print("-" * 70) print() def makeChoices(): """ Make choice grid. Later options should (intuitively) give more attacks. [ MPAonly, (text,switch)* ] """ global OPTS, ARGS choices = [] if OPTS.alltypes: choices.append([ False, \ ("no type flaws",["--match=0"]), \ ("basic type flaws",["--match=1"]), \ ("all type flaws",["--match=2"]), \ ]) if OPTS.selfcommunication: choices.append([ True, \ ("Disallow A-A",["--extravert"]), \ ("Allow responder A-A",["--init-unique"]), \ ("Allow A-A",[]) \ ]) return choices def exploreTree( i, choices , l, options = [], mpaoptions = []): """ Each choice[x] is an array again: MPAonly, (txt,arg)* """ if i >= len(choices): return [(options,mpaoptions,findAllMPA(l, options = options, mpaoptions = mpaoptions))] mpaonly = choices[i][0] cl = choices[i][1:] res = [] for (txt,arg) in cl: print("For choice %i, selecting options %s" % (i,txt)) if mpaonly: o1 = [] o2 = arg else: o1 = arg o2 = [] res = res + exploreTree(i+1, choices, l, options = options + o1, mpaoptions = mpaoptions + o2) return res def fullScan(l, options = [], mpaoptions = []): global OPTS global ALLFOUND global ALLCLAIMS global INVOLVED global PROTNAMETOFILE global PROTFILETONAME ALLFOUND = [] ALLCLAIMS = [] INVOLVED = [] if OPTS.limit > 0: l = l[:OPTS.limit] choices = makeChoices() if len(choices) == 0: """ No choices, just evaluate """ res = findAllMPA(l, options = options, mpaoptions = mpaoptions) else: lres = exploreTree(0, choices, l, options = options, mpaoptions = mpaoptions) if len(lres) > 1: if not OPTS.pickle: showDiff(lres) allprots = set() attprots = set() invprots = set() for att in ALLFOUND: attprots.add(str(att.protocol())) for cl in ALLCLAIMS: allprots.add(str(cl.protocol)) for prot in INVOLVED: invprots.add(str(prot)) if not OPTS.pickle: print("The bottom line: we found %i protocols with multi-protocol attacks from a set of %i protocols." % (len(attprots),len(allprots))) print() print("Multi-protocol attacks were found on:") for prot in sorted(list(allprots & attprots)): print(" %s" % (prot)) print() print("No multi-protocol attacks were found on these protocols, but they caused MPA attacks:") for prot in sorted(list((allprots - attprots) & invprots)): print(" %s" % (prot)) print() print("These protocols were not involved in any MPA attacks:") for prot in sorted(list((allprots - attprots) - invprots)): print(" %s\t[%s]" % (prot,PROTNAMETOFILE[prot])) print() def bigTest(): """ Perform the tests as reported in the book. """ import os global OPTS, ARGS l = [] nl = [] """ Check for any given filenames """ if len(ARGS) == 0: # No filenames given testpath = "Protocols/MultiProtocolAttacks/" fl = os.listdir(testpath) for fn in fl: if fn.endswith(".spdl"): nl.append(fn) # Prepend again the path l = [] for fn in nl: l.append(testpath+fn) else: for fn in ARGS: l.append(fn) nl = l # Report list print("Performing multi-protocol analysis for the following protocols:", nl) fullScan(l) def main(): global OPTS, ARGS, PICKLEDATA (OPTS,ARGS) = parseArgs() if OPTS.pickle: PICKLEDATA = set() bigTest() #simpleTest() if OPTS.pickle: pf = open(OPTS.pickle,"wa") for el in PICKLEDATA: json.dump(el,pf) pf.write("\n") pf.close() if __name__ == '__main__': main() # vim: set ts=4 sw=4 et list lcs=tab\:>-: