Thu Mar 16 14:58:27 CET 2006 roivas:test% nice ./night.sh Running full night script ./compareheuristics.py G-sel Decide Attack Proof Bound TOuts Claims Prots States BndTo*Sts 1 69[+]% 217[+] 145[+] 118[-] 41[-] 521 118 338025[-] 8545610025[-] 2 66% 217[+] 131 132 41[-] 521 118 365002 10924144858 3 69[+]% 217[+] 145[+] 118[-] 41[-] 521 118 309381[-] 7821461061[-] 4 57% 199 101 158 63 521 118 683177 33367047857 5 66% 193 154[+] 116[-] 58 521 118 587390 17783819640 6 64% 197 139 133 52 521 118 600111 20538798975 7 66% 193 154[+] 116[-] 58 521 118 580139 17564288364 Goal selector scan completed. 38 shared problem protocols: ['/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/SPORE/needham-schroeder-lowe.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/SPORE/kaochow-v2.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/SPORE/needham-schroeder-sk.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/SPORE/denning-sacco-lowe.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/SPORE/kaochow-v3.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/SPORE/ksl.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/SPORE/ksl-lowe.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/SPORE/denning-sacco.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/SPORE/needham-schroeder-sk-amend.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/SPORE/key-compromise/needham-schroeder-sk.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/SPORE/andrew-ban-concrete.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/SPORE/wmf.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/SPORE/yahalom.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/SPORE/wmf-lowe.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/SPORE/needham-schroeder.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/misc/nsl7.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/misc/f4.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/misc/bke-generalized-4.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/misc/isoiec11770-2-13.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/misc/gong-nonce-b.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/misc/ksl.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/misc/denning-sacco-shared.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/misc/f5.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/misc/nsl-generalized-4.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/misc/kaochow-v2.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/misc/kaochow-palm.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/misc/ns-symmetric-amended.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/misc/ns-symmetric.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/misc/gong-nonce.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/misc/localclaims-seq1.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/misc/splice-as-hc-cj.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/misc/kaochow-v3.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/misc/localclaims-breaker.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/misc/mnsl4-private.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/misc/bunava-1-4.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/misc/tls-paulson.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/multiparty/mn30.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/multiparty/mn40.spdl'] 1 has 5 extra problems: ['/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/SPORE/ccitt509-3.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/misc/nsl3.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/misc/nsl3-nisynch-rep.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/multiparty/mn20.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/demo/nsl3.spdl'] 2 has 11 extra problems: ['/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/SPORE/yahalom-lowe.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/SPORE/otwayrees.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/SPORE/ccitt509-ban3.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/SPORE/andrew-ban.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/misc/andrew-ban.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/misc/nsl3.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/misc/ccitt509-ban.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/misc/yahalom-lowe.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/misc/nsl3-nisynch-rep.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/multiparty/mn20.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/demo/nsl3.spdl'] 3 has 5 extra problems: ['/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/SPORE/ccitt509-3.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/misc/nsl3.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/misc/nsl3-nisynch-rep.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/multiparty/mn20.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/demo/nsl3.spdl'] 4 has 22 extra problems: ['/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/SPORE/yahalom-lowe.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/SPORE/otwayrees.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/SPORE/kaochow.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/SPORE/ccitt509-3.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/SPORE/yahalom-paulson.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/SPORE/woo-lam.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/SPORE/neumannstub-hwang.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/SPORE/neumannstub.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/SPORE/andrew-ban.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/SPORE/yahalom-ban.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/SPORE/andrew.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/misc/andrew-ban.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/misc/bke-broken.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/misc/bke-one.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/misc/yahalom-paulson.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/misc/woolam-cmv.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/misc/otwayrees.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/misc/kaochow.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/misc/bke-variation.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/misc/yahalom-lowe.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/misc/bke.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/misc/unknown2.spdl'] 5 has 7 extra problems: ['/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/SPORE/otwayrees.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/SPORE/kaochow.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/SPORE/ccitt509-3.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/SPORE/neumannstub.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/misc/yahalom-paulson.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/misc/kaochow.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/misc/unknown2.spdl'] 6 has 13 extra problems: ['/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/SPORE/yahalom-lowe.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/SPORE/otwayrees.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/SPORE/kaochow.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/SPORE/ccitt509-3.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/SPORE/neumannstub-hwang.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/SPORE/neumannstub.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/SPORE/andrew-ban.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/SPORE/yahalom-ban.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/misc/andrew-ban.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/misc/yahalom-paulson.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/misc/kaochow.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/misc/yahalom-lowe.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/misc/unknown2.spdl'] 7 has 7 extra problems: ['/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/SPORE/otwayrees.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/SPORE/kaochow.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/SPORE/ccitt509-3.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/SPORE/neumannstub.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/misc/yahalom-paulson.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/misc/kaochow.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/misc/unknown2.spdl'] ./compareheuristics.py -m 2 G-sel Decide Attack Proof Bound TOuts Claims Prots States BndTo*Sts 1 43[+]% 182[+] 47[+] 102[-] 190[-] 521 118 1125475[-] 95962500400 2 40% 167 45 90[-] 219 521 118 1332318 127211054958 3 43[+]% 182[+] 47[+] 104 188[-] 521 118 1121841[-] 95652651024 4 44[+]% 202[+] 30 138 151[-] 521 118 721850[-] 60289633850 5 46[+]% 193 48[+] 108 172 521 118 886795 69524728000 6 48[+]% 205[+] 46 115 155 521 118 908916 66259976400 7 47% 197 48[+] 110 166 521 118 858497 65396867472 Goal selector scan completed. 61 shared problem protocols: ['/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/SPORE/needham-schroeder-lowe.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/SPORE/kaochow-v2.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/SPORE/yahalom-lowe.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/SPORE/needham-schroeder-sk.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/SPORE/kaochow.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/SPORE/ccitt509-3.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/SPORE/woo-lam.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/SPORE/neumannstub-hwang.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/SPORE/kaochow-v3.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/SPORE/ccitt509-ban3.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/SPORE/ksl.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/SPORE/ksl-lowe.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/SPORE/neumannstub.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/SPORE/needham-schroeder-sk-amend.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/SPORE/key-compromise/needham-schroeder-sk.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/SPORE/andrew-ban-concrete.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/SPORE/andrew-ban.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/SPORE/wmf.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/SPORE/yahalom.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/SPORE/wmf-lowe.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/SPORE/needham-schroeder.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/misc/andrew-ban.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/misc/nsl3.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/misc/bke-broken.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/misc/nsl7.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/misc/ns3-brutus.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/misc/bke-generalized-4.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/misc/isoiec11770-2-13.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/misc/gong-nonce-b.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/misc/ksl.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/misc/denning-sacco-shared.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/misc/woolam-cmv.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/misc/f5.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/misc/ccitt509-ban.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/misc/nsl-generalized-4.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/misc/wmf-brutus.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/misc/kaochow-v2.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/misc/kaochow-palm.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/misc/ns-symmetric-amended.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/misc/ns-symmetric.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/misc/gong-nonce.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/misc/kaochow.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/misc/localclaims-seq1.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/misc/yahalom-lowe.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/misc/splice-as-hc-cj.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/misc/soph.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/misc/kaochow-v3.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/misc/unknown2.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/misc/speedtest.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/misc/yahalom.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/misc/ns3.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/misc/localclaims-breaker.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/misc/nsl3-nisynch-rep.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/misc/mnsl4-private.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/misc/bunava-1-4.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/misc/tls-paulson.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/multiparty/mn20.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/multiparty/mn30.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/multiparty/mn40.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/demo/nsl3.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/demo/ns3.spdl'] 1 has 5 extra problems: ['/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/SPORE/otwayrees.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/SPORE/andrew.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/misc/splice-as.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/misc/splice-as-hc.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/misc/otwayrees.spdl'] 2 has 5 extra problems: ['/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/SPORE/otwayrees.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/SPORE/andrew.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/misc/splice-as.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/misc/splice-as-hc.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/misc/otwayrees.spdl'] 3 has 5 extra problems: ['/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/SPORE/otwayrees.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/SPORE/andrew.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/misc/splice-as.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/misc/splice-as-hc.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/misc/otwayrees.spdl'] 4 has 4 extra problems: ['/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/SPORE/andrew.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/misc/bke-one.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/misc/bke-variation.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/misc/bke.spdl'] 5 has 2 extra problems: ['/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/misc/splice-as.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/misc/splice-as-hc.spdl'] 6 has 0 extra problems: [] 7 has 2 extra problems: ['/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/misc/splice-as.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/misc/splice-as-hc.spdl'] ./compareheuristics.py -b 2 G-sel Decide Attack Proof Bound TOuts Claims Prots States BndTo*Sts 1 66[+]% 167[+] 177[+] 27[-] 150[-] 521 118 10719016[-] 335816052264 2 71[+]% 188[+] 184[+] 25[-] 124[-] 521 118 11017256 244594100456 3 67% 172 178 27 144 521 118 10414630[-] 304534195830 4 64% 182 153 63 123[-] 521 118 7257715[-] 251087908140 5 66% 169 175 40 137 521 118 7187803[-] 225186680187 6 65% 169 171 39 142 521 118 8263514 270720982154 7 66% 169 175 40 137 521 118 6976206[-] 218557557774 Goal selector scan completed. 21 shared problem protocols: ['/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/SPORE/needham-schroeder-sk.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/SPORE/denning-sacco-lowe.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/SPORE/kaochow-v3.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/SPORE/denning-sacco.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/SPORE/needham-schroeder-sk-amend.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/SPORE/key-compromise/needham-schroeder-sk.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/SPORE/andrew-ban-concrete.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/SPORE/wmf.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/SPORE/wmf-lowe.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/misc/nsl7.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/misc/f4.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/misc/bke-generalized-4.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/misc/denning-sacco-shared.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/misc/f5.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/misc/nsl-generalized-4.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/misc/kaochow-palm.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/misc/ns-symmetric-amended.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/misc/ns-symmetric.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/misc/localclaims-seq1.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/misc/kaochow-v3.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/multiparty/mn40.spdl'] 1 has 12 extra problems: ['/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/SPORE/needham-schroeder-lowe.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/SPORE/kaochow-v2.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/SPORE/ksl.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/SPORE/ksl-lowe.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/SPORE/needham-schroeder.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/misc/yahalom-ban.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/misc/ksl.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/misc/kaochow-v2.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/misc/bunava-1-3.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/misc/mnsl4-private.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/misc/bunava-1-4.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/multiparty/mn30.spdl'] 2 has 7 extra problems: ['/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/SPORE/needham-schroeder.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/misc/yahalom-ban.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/misc/bunava-1-3.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/misc/localclaims-breaker.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/misc/mnsl4-private.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/misc/bunava-1-4.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/multiparty/mn30.spdl'] 3 has 11 extra problems: ['/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/SPORE/kaochow-v2.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/SPORE/ksl.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/SPORE/needham-schroeder.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/misc/yahalom-ban.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/misc/ksl.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/misc/kaochow-v2.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/misc/bunava-1-3.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/misc/localclaims-breaker.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/misc/mnsl4-private.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/misc/bunava-1-4.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/multiparty/mn30.spdl'] 4 has 18 extra problems: ['/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/SPORE/kaochow-v2.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/SPORE/kaochow.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/SPORE/ksl.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/SPORE/ksl-lowe.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/SPORE/andrew.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/misc/bke-broken.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/misc/splice-as.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/misc/bke-one.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/misc/ksl.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/misc/kaochow-v2.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/misc/gong-nonce.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/misc/kaochow.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/misc/bke-variation.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/misc/bke.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/misc/localclaims-breaker.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/misc/mnsl4-private.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/misc/tls-paulson.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/multiparty/mn30.spdl'] 5 has 13 extra problems: ['/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/SPORE/kaochow-v2.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/SPORE/kaochow.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/SPORE/ksl.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/SPORE/ksl-lowe.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/misc/gong-nonce-b.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/misc/ksl.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/misc/kaochow-v2.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/misc/gong-nonce.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/misc/kaochow.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/misc/bunava-1-3.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/misc/localclaims-breaker.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/misc/bunava-1-4.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/misc/tls-paulson.spdl'] 6 has 14 extra problems: ['/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/SPORE/kaochow-v2.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/SPORE/kaochow.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/SPORE/ksl.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/SPORE/ksl-lowe.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/misc/gong-nonce-b.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/misc/ksl.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/misc/kaochow-v2.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/misc/gong-nonce.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/misc/kaochow.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/misc/bunava-1-3.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/misc/localclaims-breaker.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/misc/mnsl4-private.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/misc/bunava-1-4.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/misc/tls-paulson.spdl'] 7 has 13 extra problems: ['/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/SPORE/kaochow-v2.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/SPORE/kaochow.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/SPORE/ksl.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/SPORE/ksl-lowe.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/misc/gong-nonce-b.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/misc/ksl.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/misc/kaochow-v2.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/misc/gong-nonce.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/misc/kaochow.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/misc/bunava-1-3.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/misc/localclaims-breaker.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/misc/bunava-1-4.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/misc/tls-paulson.spdl'] ./compareheuristics.py -b 2 -m 2 G-sel Decide Attack Proof Bound TOuts Claims Prots States BndTo*Sts 1 23[+]% 72[+] 51[+] 8[-] 390[-] 521 118 5419084[-] 858404581936 2 23[+]% 72[+] 51[+] 8[-] 390[-] 521 118 5578015 883579888060 3 23[+]% 72[+] 51[+] 8[-] 390[-] 521 118 5324085[-] 843356360340 4 24[+]% 98[+] 30 31 362[-] 521 118 4291751[-] 662856650199 5 25[+]% 88 47 14 372 521 118 5223320 778253786720 6 25[+]% 88 45 14 374 521 118 5680220 855123039680 7 25[+]% 88 47 17 369 521 118 5286327 787641577692 Goal selector scan completed. 67 shared problem protocols: ['/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/SPORE/needham-schroeder-lowe.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/SPORE/kaochow-v2.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/SPORE/yahalom-lowe.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/SPORE/otwayrees.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/SPORE/needham-schroeder-sk.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/SPORE/kaochow.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/SPORE/ccitt509-3.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/SPORE/denning-sacco-lowe.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/SPORE/woo-lam.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/SPORE/neumannstub-hwang.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/SPORE/kaochow-v3.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/SPORE/ccitt509-ban3.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/SPORE/ksl.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/SPORE/ksl-lowe.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/SPORE/neumannstub.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/SPORE/woo-lam-pi-f.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/SPORE/needham-schroeder-sk-amend.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/SPORE/key-compromise/needham-schroeder-sk.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/SPORE/andrew-ban-concrete.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/SPORE/andrew-ban.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/SPORE/wmf.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/SPORE/yahalom.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/SPORE/wmf-lowe.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/SPORE/needham-schroeder.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/misc/andrew-ban.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/misc/nsl3.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/misc/bke-broken.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/misc/splice-as.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/misc/nsl7.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/misc/ns3-brutus.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/misc/woolam-pi-f.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/misc/bke-generalized-4.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/misc/splice-as-hc.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/misc/isoiec11770-2-13.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/misc/gong-nonce-b.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/misc/ksl.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/misc/denning-sacco-shared.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/misc/woolam-cmv.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/misc/ccitt509-ban.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/misc/nsl-generalized-4.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/misc/wmf-brutus.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/misc/kaochow-v2.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/misc/otwayrees.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/misc/kaochow-palm.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/misc/ns-symmetric-amended.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/misc/ns-symmetric.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/misc/gong-nonce.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/misc/kaochow.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/misc/localclaims-seq1.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/misc/yahalom-lowe.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/misc/splice-as-hc-cj.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/misc/soph.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/misc/bunava-1-3.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/misc/kaochow-v3.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/misc/unknown2.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/misc/speedtest.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/misc/yahalom.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/misc/ns3.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/misc/localclaims-breaker.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/misc/nsl3-nisynch-rep.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/misc/mnsl4-private.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/misc/bunava-1-4.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/multiparty/mn20.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/multiparty/mn30.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/multiparty/mn40.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/demo/nsl3.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/demo/ns3.spdl'] 1 has 7 extra problems: ['/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/SPORE/yahalom-paulson.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/SPORE/woo-lam-pi-2.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/SPORE/yahalom-ban.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/SPORE/woo-lam-pi-1.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/SPORE/woo-lam-pi-3.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/misc/yahalom-ban.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/misc/yahalom-paulson.spdl'] 2 has 7 extra problems: ['/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/SPORE/yahalom-paulson.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/SPORE/woo-lam-pi-2.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/SPORE/yahalom-ban.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/SPORE/woo-lam-pi-1.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/SPORE/woo-lam-pi-3.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/misc/yahalom-ban.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/misc/yahalom-paulson.spdl'] 3 has 7 extra problems: ['/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/SPORE/yahalom-paulson.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/SPORE/woo-lam-pi-2.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/SPORE/yahalom-ban.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/SPORE/woo-lam-pi-1.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/SPORE/woo-lam-pi-3.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/misc/yahalom-ban.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/misc/yahalom-paulson.spdl'] 4 has 5 extra problems: ['/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/SPORE/andrew.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/misc/bke-one.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/misc/bke-variation.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/misc/bke.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/misc/tls-paulson.spdl'] 5 has 6 extra problems: ['/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/SPORE/woo-lam-pi-2.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/SPORE/woo-lam-pi-1.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/SPORE/andrew.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/SPORE/woo-lam-pi-3.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/misc/yahalom-paulson.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/misc/tls-paulson.spdl'] 6 has 6 extra problems: ['/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/SPORE/woo-lam-pi-2.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/SPORE/woo-lam-pi-1.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/SPORE/andrew.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/SPORE/woo-lam-pi-3.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/misc/yahalom-paulson.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/misc/tls-paulson.spdl'] 7 has 6 extra problems: ['/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/SPORE/woo-lam-pi-2.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/SPORE/woo-lam-pi-1.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/SPORE/andrew.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/SPORE/woo-lam-pi-3.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/misc/yahalom-paulson.spdl', '/home/cas/svn/ecss/protocols/spdl/misc/tls-paulson.spdl'] roivas:test% nice ./night.sh R