From 391033ec3e05090e47749cf78453259fc8e9219d Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: ccremers Date: Wed, 9 Mar 2005 21:41:30 +0000 Subject: [PATCH] - Performed some more tests. Stored the results. --- test/protocollist.py | 2 +- test/results/test-s-a-B-b0-p1.txt | 469 ++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ 2 files changed, 470 insertions(+), 1 deletion(-) create mode 100644 test/results/test-s-a-B-b0-p1.txt diff --git a/test/protocollist.py b/test/protocollist.py index 66877b1..b9d9cb9 100644 --- a/test/protocollist.py +++ b/test/protocollist.py @@ -20,7 +20,6 @@ def from_literature(): "gong-nonce-b.spdl", "gong-nonce.spdl", "isoiec11770-2-13.spdl", - "kaochow-palm.spdl", "kaochow.spdl", "kaochow-v2.spdl", "kaochow-v3.spdl", @@ -61,6 +60,7 @@ def from_others(): "carkey-ni.spdl", "five-run-bound.spdl", "helloworld.spdl", + "kaochow-palm.spdl", "ns3-brutus.spdl", "nsl3-nisynch-rep.spdl", "onetrace.spdl", diff --git a/test/results/test-s-a-B-b0-p1.txt b/test/results/test-s-a-B-b0-p1.txt new file mode 100644 index 0000000..babddee --- /dev/null +++ b/test/results/test-s-a-B-b0-p1.txt @@ -0,0 +1,469 @@ + +**************************************** + Testing multiple tuple widths +**************************************** + + +**************************************** + Testing tuple width 2 +**************************************** + + +**************************************** + Testing multiple match methods +**************************************** + + +**************************************** + Testing match 0 +**************************************** + +Evaluating 561 tuples of 2 for 34 protocols. +Testing 1 tuples using --summary --match=0 --arachne --timer=4 --max-runs=4 --max-length=18 +Evaluated single results. +Correct protocols: ['ccitt509', 'kaochow', 'yahalomBan', 'yahalomlowe', 'kaochow2', 'kaochow3', 'nssymmetric', 'otwayrees', 'wmfbrutus', 'bke', 'soph', 'nsl3', 'nsl7', 'denningsaccosh', 'yahalom', 'sophkx', 'isoiec11770213', 'woolamce', 'nssymmetricamended', 'kaochowPalm', 'andrewBan'] +Partly flawed protocols: ['woolamcmv', 'andrewLoweBan', 'ksl', 'boyd', 'yahalompaulson', 'gongnonce', 'ns3', 'gongnonceb', 'spliceAShcCJ'] +Completely flawed protocols: ['spliceAS', 'woolampif', 'tmn', 'spliceAShc'] +Testing 2 tuples using --summary --match=0 --arachne --timer=4 --max-runs=4 --max-length=18 +*** 0 290/561 kaochow IV Niagree_6 nsl7 +*** 1 290/561 kaochow RV Nisynch_8 nsl7 +*** 2 290/561 kaochow RV Niagree_9 nsl7 +*** 3 290/561 kaochow IV Nisynch_5 nsl7 +*** 4 312/561 kaochow2 RV Nisynch_8 nsl7 +*** 5 312/561 kaochow2 RV Niagree_9 nsl7 +*** 6 312/561 kaochow2 IV Niagree_6 nsl7 +*** 7 312/561 kaochow2 IV Nisynch_5 nsl7 +*** 8 333/561 kaochow3 IV Niagree_6 nsl7 +*** 9 333/561 kaochow3 RV Nisynch_8 nsl7 +*** 10 333/561 kaochow3 RV Niagree_9 nsl7 +*** 11 333/561 kaochow3 IV Nisynch_5 nsl7 +*** 12 377/561 ns3 IV Secret_i1 soph +*** 13 377/561 ns3 IV Secret_i2 soph +*** 14 377/561 ns3 IV Niagree_i3 soph +*** 15 377/561 ns3 IV Nisynch_i4 soph +*** 16 379/561 ns3 IV Secret_i2 spliceAShc +*** 17 380/561 ns3 IV Secret_i2 spliceAS +*** 18 395/561 nsl3 RV Secret_r1 soph +*** 19 395/561 nsl3 IV Secret_i2 soph +*** 20 395/561 nsl3 IV Secret_i1 soph +*** 21 395/561 nsl3 IV Nisynch_i4 soph +*** 22 395/561 nsl3 IV Niagree_i3 soph +*** 23 397/561 nsl3 RV Secret_r2 spliceAShc +*** 24 397/561 nsl3 IV Secret_i2 spliceAShc +*** 25 398/561 nsl3 RV Secret_r2 spliceAS +*** 26 398/561 nsl3 IV Secret_i2 spliceAS +*** 27 483/561 spliceAShcCJ CV Secret_7 soph +*** 28 483/561 spliceAShcCJ SV Secret_8 soph +*** 29 495/561 spliceAShcCJ CV Secret_7 spliceAShc +*** 30 495/561 spliceAShcCJ SV Secret_8 spliceAShc +*** 31 496/561 spliceAShcCJ CV Secret_7 spliceAS +*** 32 496/561 spliceAShcCJ SV Secret_8 spliceAS +*** 33 536/561 wmfbrutus BV Secret_3 yahalomBan +*** 34 557/561 yahalom BV Secret_6 yahalomBan +*** 35 559/561 yahalomlowe IV Niagree_9 yahalom +*** 36 559/561 yahalomlowe IV Nisynch_10 yahalom +Processed 561 tuple combinations in total. +Found 37 new attacks. + These were helped by: + nsl7: All-Correct. This possibly breaks ['kaochow', 'kaochow2', 'kaochow3'] + spliceAS: All-Flawed. This possibly breaks ['ns3', 'nsl3', 'spliceAShcCJ'] + yahalom: All-Correct. This possibly breaks ['yahalomlowe'] + yahalomBan: All-Correct. This possibly breaks ['wmfbrutus', 'yahalom'] + spliceAShc: All-Flawed. This possibly breaks ['ns3', 'nsl3', 'spliceAShcCJ'] + soph: All-Correct. This possibly breaks ['ns3', 'nsl3', 'spliceAShcCJ'] + +**************************************** + Testing match 1 +**************************************** + +Evaluating 561 tuples of 2 for 34 protocols. +Testing 1 tuples using --summary --match=1 --arachne --timer=4 --max-runs=4 --max-length=18 +Evaluated single results. +Correct protocols: ['ccitt509', 'kaochow', 'yahalomBan', 'yahalomlowe', 'kaochow2', 'kaochow3', 'nssymmetric', 'otwayrees', 'wmfbrutus', 'bke', 'soph', 'nsl3', 'nsl7', 'denningsaccosh', 'yahalom', 'sophkx', 'isoiec11770213', 'woolamce', 'nssymmetricamended', 'kaochowPalm', 'andrewBan'] +Partly flawed protocols: ['woolamcmv', 'andrewLoweBan', 'ksl', 'boyd', 'yahalompaulson', 'gongnonce', 'ns3', 'gongnonceb', 'spliceAShcCJ'] +Completely flawed protocols: ['spliceAS', 'woolampif', 'tmn', 'spliceAShc'] +Testing 2 tuples using --summary --match=1 --arachne --timer=4 --max-runs=4 --max-length=18 +*** 0 121/561 boyd RV Secret_10 woolampif +*** 1 121/561 boyd IV Secret_6 woolampif +*** 2 125/561 boyd RV Secret_10 yahalom +*** 3 125/561 boyd IV Secret_6 yahalom +*** 4 144/561 ccitt509 RV Secret_8 spliceAShc +*** 5 144/561 ccitt509 RV Secret_9 spliceAShc +*** 6 145/561 ccitt509 RV Secret_9 spliceAS +*** 7 145/561 ccitt509 RV Secret_8 spliceAS +*** 8 145/561 ccitt509 IV Secret_5 spliceAS +*** 9 145/561 ccitt509 IV Secret_4 spliceAS +*** 10 146/561 ccitt509 RV Secret_8 tmn +*** 11 146/561 ccitt509 IV Secret_5 tmn +*** 12 146/561 ccitt509 IV Secret_4 tmn +*** 13 146/561 ccitt509 RV Secret_9 tmn +*** 14 159/561 kaochow RV Secret_10 denningsaccosh +*** 15 159/561 kaochow RV Niagree_9 denningsaccosh +*** 16 177/561 woolamcmv BV Secret_11 denningsaccosh +*** 17 177/561 denningsaccosh AV Secret_4 woolamcmv +*** 18 177/561 woolamcmv AV Secret_8 denningsaccosh +*** 19 177/561 denningsaccosh AV Niagree_6 woolamcmv +*** 20 177/561 denningsaccosh AV Nisynch_5 woolamcmv +*** 21 177/561 woolamcmv SV Secret_14 denningsaccosh +*** 22 180/561 denningsaccosh AV Niagree_6 yahalomlowe +*** 23 180/561 denningsaccosh AV Nisynch_5 yahalomlowe +*** 24 218/561 gongnonce IV Niagree_9 nsl7 +*** 25 218/561 gongnonce IV Nisynch_8 nsl7 +*** 26 301/561 kaochow RV Secret_10 woolamce +*** 27 301/561 kaochow IV Niagree_6 woolamce +*** 28 301/561 kaochow RV Nisynch_8 woolamce +*** 29 301/561 kaochow RV Niagree_9 woolamce +*** 30 301/561 kaochow IV Secret_7 woolamce +*** 31 301/561 kaochow IV Nisynch_5 woolamce +*** 32 303/561 kaochow RV Secret_10 woolampif +*** 33 303/561 kaochow IV Niagree_6 woolampif +*** 34 303/561 kaochow RV Nisynch_8 woolampif +*** 35 303/561 kaochow RV Niagree_9 woolampif +*** 36 303/561 kaochow IV Nisynch_5 woolampif +*** 37 305/561 kaochow RV Secret_10 yahalomlowe +*** 38 305/561 kaochow IV Niagree_6 yahalomlowe +*** 39 305/561 kaochow IV Nisynch_5 yahalomlowe +*** 40 305/561 kaochow RV Nisynch_8 yahalomlowe +*** 41 305/561 kaochow RV Niagree_9 yahalomlowe +*** 42 306/561 kaochow RV Secret_10 yahalompaulson +*** 43 306/561 kaochow IV Niagree_6 yahalompaulson +*** 44 306/561 yahalompaulson RV Secret_11 kaochow +*** 45 306/561 kaochow RV Nisynch_8 yahalompaulson +*** 46 306/561 kaochow RV Niagree_9 yahalompaulson +*** 47 306/561 yahalompaulson IV Secret_8 kaochow +*** 48 306/561 kaochow IV Nisynch_5 yahalompaulson +*** 49 381/561 ns3 IV Secret_i2 tmn +*** 50 390/561 nsl3 IV Nisynch_i4 nsl7 +*** 51 390/561 nsl3 IV Niagree_i3 nsl7 +*** 52 399/561 nsl3 RV Secret_r2 tmn +*** 53 399/561 nsl3 IV Secret_i2 tmn +*** 54 469/561 otwayrees BV Secret_6 yahalom +*** 55 470/561 sophkx IV Secret_4 soph +*** 56 497/561 spliceAShcCJ CV Secret_7 tmn +*** 57 497/561 spliceAShcCJ SV Secret_8 tmn +*** 58 538/561 wmfbrutus BV Secret_3 yahalompaulson +*** 59 548/561 woolamcmv AV Secret_8 yahalomlowe +*** 60 548/561 yahalomlowe IV Niagree_9 woolamcmv +*** 61 548/561 yahalomlowe IV Secret_8 woolamcmv +*** 62 548/561 yahalomlowe IV Nisynch_10 woolamcmv +*** 63 548/561 woolamcmv SV Secret_14 yahalomlowe +*** 64 549/561 yahalompaulson RV Secret_11 woolamcmv +*** 65 553/561 yahalompaulson RV Secret_11 woolampif +*** 66 560/561 yahalom BV Secret_6 yahalompaulson +Processed 561 tuple combinations in total. +Found 67 new attacks. + These were helped by: + woolamcmv: Mixed. This possibly breaks ['denningsaccosh', 'yahalomlowe', 'yahalompaulson'] + kaochow: All-Correct. This possibly breaks ['yahalompaulson'] + nsl7: All-Correct. This possibly breaks ['gongnonce', 'kaochow', 'nsl3'] + denningsaccosh: All-Correct. This possibly breaks ['kaochow', 'woolamcmv'] + spliceAS: All-Flawed. This possibly breaks ['ccitt509', 'ns3', 'nsl3', 'spliceAShcCJ'] + yahalom: All-Correct. This possibly breaks ['boyd', 'otwayrees', 'yahalomlowe'] + woolampif: All-Flawed. This possibly breaks ['boyd', 'kaochow', 'yahalompaulson'] + yahalomBan: All-Correct. This possibly breaks ['wmfbrutus', 'yahalom'] + spliceAShc: All-Flawed. This possibly breaks ['ccitt509', 'ns3', 'nsl3', 'spliceAShcCJ'] + woolamce: All-Correct. This possibly breaks ['kaochow'] + yahalompaulson: Mixed. This possibly breaks ['kaochow', 'wmfbrutus', 'yahalom'] + yahalomlowe: All-Correct. This possibly breaks ['denningsaccosh', 'kaochow', 'woolamcmv'] + soph: All-Correct. This possibly breaks ['nsl3', 'sophkx', 'spliceAShcCJ'] + tmn: All-Flawed. This possibly breaks ['ccitt509', 'ns3', 'nsl3', 'spliceAShcCJ'] + +**************************************** + Testing match 2 +**************************************** + +Evaluating 561 tuples of 2 for 34 protocols. +Testing 1 tuples using --summary --match=2 --arachne --timer=4 --max-runs=4 --max-length=18 +Evaluated single results. +Correct protocols: ['ccitt509', 'kaochow', 'yahalomlowe', 'kaochow2', 'kaochow3', 'nssymmetric', 'wmfbrutus', 'bke', 'soph', 'nsl3', 'nsl7', 'sophkx', 'isoiec11770213', 'woolamce', 'nssymmetricamended', 'kaochowPalm', 'andrewBan'] +Partly flawed protocols: ['woolamcmv', 'andrewLoweBan', 'ksl', 'boyd', 'gongnonce', 'ns3', 'gongnonceb', 'denningsaccosh', 'yahalom', 'spliceAShcCJ'] +Completely flawed protocols: ['spliceAS', 'yahalomBan', 'otwayrees', 'woolampif', 'tmn', 'spliceAShc', 'yahalompaulson'] +Testing 2 tuples using --summary --match=2 --arachne --timer=4 --max-runs=4 --max-length=18 +*** 0 118/561 wmfbrutus BV Secret_3 boyd +*** 1 119/561 boyd RV Secret_10 woolamce +*** 2 119/561 boyd IV Secret_6 woolamce +*** 3 122/561 boyd RV Secret_10 yahalomBan +*** 4 122/561 boyd IV Secret_6 yahalomBan +*** 5 124/561 boyd RV Secret_10 yahalompaulson +*** 6 124/561 boyd IV Secret_6 yahalompaulson +*** 7 138/561 ccitt509 IV Secret_5 nssymmetricamended +*** 8 138/561 ccitt509 RV Secret_8 nssymmetricamended +*** 9 138/561 ccitt509 RV Secret_9 nssymmetricamended +*** 10 138/561 ccitt509 IV Secret_4 nssymmetricamended +*** 11 139/561 ccitt509 IV Secret_4 nssymmetric +*** 12 139/561 ccitt509 RV Secret_8 nssymmetric +*** 13 139/561 ccitt509 RV Secret_9 nssymmetric +*** 14 139/561 ccitt509 IV Secret_5 nssymmetric +*** 15 157/561 denningsaccosh BV Niagree_9 isoiec11770213 +*** 16 166/561 denningsaccosh BV Secret_7 nssymmetricamended +*** 17 166/561 denningsaccosh BV Niagree_9 nssymmetricamended +*** 18 167/561 denningsaccosh BV Niagree_9 nssymmetric +*** 19 167/561 denningsaccosh BV Secret_7 nssymmetric +*** 20 168/561 denningsaccosh BV Niagree_9 otwayrees +*** 21 175/561 denningsaccosh AV Niagree_6 wmfbrutus +*** 22 175/561 denningsaccosh BV Niagree_9 wmfbrutus +*** 23 179/561 denningsaccosh AV Secret_4 yahalomBan +*** 24 179/561 denningsaccosh AV Niagree_6 yahalomBan +*** 25 180/561 yahalomlowe RV Niagree_13 denningsaccosh +*** 26 180/561 yahalomlowe RV Nisynch_12 denningsaccosh +*** 27 180/561 yahalomlowe RV Secret_11 denningsaccosh +*** 28 181/561 denningsaccosh AV Secret_4 yahalompaulson +*** 29 181/561 denningsaccosh AV Niagree_6 yahalompaulson +*** 30 182/561 denningsaccosh AV Niagree_6 yahalom +*** 31 186/561 kaochow RV Secret_10 gongnonceb +*** 32 186/561 kaochow RV Nisynch_8 gongnonceb +*** 33 186/561 kaochow RV Niagree_9 gongnonceb +*** 34 202/561 wmfbrutus BV Secret_3 gongnonceb +*** 35 212/561 kaochow RV Secret_10 gongnonce +*** 36 213/561 kaochow2 RV Secret_10 gongnonce +*** 37 214/561 kaochow3 RV Secret_10 gongnonce +*** 38 228/561 wmfbrutus BV Secret_3 gongnonce +*** 39 253/561 wmfbrutus BV Secret_3 isoiec11770213 +*** 40 277/561 wmfbrutus BV Secret_3 kaochowPalm +*** 41 300/561 wmfbrutus BV Secret_3 kaochow +*** 42 303/561 kaochow IV Secret_7 woolampif +*** 43 304/561 kaochow RV Secret_10 yahalomBan +*** 44 304/561 kaochow IV Niagree_6 yahalomBan +*** 45 304/561 kaochow RV Nisynch_8 yahalomBan +*** 46 304/561 kaochow RV Niagree_9 yahalomBan +*** 47 304/561 kaochow IV Secret_7 yahalomBan +*** 48 304/561 kaochow IV Nisynch_5 yahalomBan +*** 49 306/561 kaochow IV Secret_7 yahalompaulson +*** 50 322/561 wmfbrutus BV Secret_3 kaochow2 +*** 51 325/561 kaochow2 RV Nisynch_8 woolampif +*** 52 325/561 kaochow2 RV Niagree_9 woolampif +*** 53 325/561 kaochow2 IV Niagree_6 woolampif +*** 54 325/561 kaochow2 IV Secret_7 woolampif +*** 55 325/561 kaochow2 IV Nisynch_5 woolampif +*** 56 325/561 kaochow2 RV Secret_10 woolampif +*** 57 326/561 kaochow2 RV Nisynch_8 yahalomBan +*** 58 326/561 kaochow2 RV Niagree_9 yahalomBan +*** 59 326/561 kaochow2 IV Niagree_6 yahalomBan +*** 60 326/561 kaochow2 IV Secret_7 yahalomBan +*** 61 326/561 kaochow2 IV Nisynch_5 yahalomBan +*** 62 326/561 kaochow2 RV Secret_10 yahalomBan +*** 63 328/561 kaochow2 RV Nisynch_8 yahalompaulson +*** 64 328/561 kaochow2 RV Niagree_9 yahalompaulson +*** 65 328/561 kaochow2 IV Secret_7 yahalompaulson +*** 66 328/561 kaochow2 IV Niagree_6 yahalompaulson +*** 67 328/561 kaochow2 IV Nisynch_5 yahalompaulson +*** 68 328/561 kaochow2 RV Secret_10 yahalompaulson +*** 69 343/561 wmfbrutus BV Secret_3 kaochow3 +*** 70 346/561 kaochow3 RV Secret_10 woolampif +*** 71 346/561 kaochow3 IV Niagree_6 woolampif +*** 72 346/561 kaochow3 RV Nisynch_8 woolampif +*** 73 346/561 kaochow3 RV Niagree_9 woolampif +*** 74 346/561 kaochow3 IV Secret_7 woolampif +*** 75 346/561 kaochow3 IV Nisynch_5 woolampif +*** 76 347/561 kaochow3 RV Secret_10 yahalomBan +*** 77 347/561 kaochow3 RV Niagree_9 yahalomBan +*** 78 349/561 kaochow3 RV Secret_10 yahalompaulson +*** 79 349/561 kaochow3 RV Nisynch_8 yahalompaulson +*** 80 349/561 kaochow3 IV Niagree_6 yahalompaulson +*** 81 349/561 kaochow3 IV Secret_7 yahalompaulson +*** 82 349/561 kaochow3 IV Nisynch_5 yahalompaulson +*** 83 349/561 kaochow3 RV Niagree_9 yahalompaulson +*** 84 363/561 wmfbrutus BV Secret_3 ksl +*** 85 371/561 ns3 IV Niagree_i3 nsl3 +*** 86 371/561 ns3 IV Nisynch_i4 nsl3 +*** 87 372/561 ns3 IV Niagree_i3 nsl7 +*** 88 372/561 ns3 IV Nisynch_i4 nsl7 +*** 89 373/561 ns3 IV Secret_i2 nssymmetricamended +*** 90 374/561 ns3 IV Secret_i2 nssymmetric +*** 91 391/561 nsl3 RV Secret_r2 nssymmetricamended +*** 92 391/561 nsl3 IV Secret_i2 nssymmetricamended +*** 93 392/561 nsl3 RV Secret_r2 nssymmetric +*** 94 392/561 nsl3 IV Secret_i2 nssymmetric +*** 95 429/561 spliceAShcCJ CV Secret_7 nssymmetricamended +*** 96 429/561 spliceAShcCJ SV Secret_8 nssymmetricamended +*** 97 444/561 spliceAShcCJ CV Secret_7 nssymmetric +*** 98 444/561 spliceAShcCJ SV Secret_8 nssymmetric +*** 99 533/561 wmfbrutus BV Secret_3 woolamce +*** 100 535/561 wmfbrutus BV Secret_3 woolampif +*** 101 537/561 yahalomlowe IV Niagree_9 wmfbrutus +*** 102 537/561 yahalomlowe IV Nisynch_10 wmfbrutus +*** 103 539/561 wmfbrutus BV Secret_3 yahalom +*** 104 542/561 woolamce BV Secret_8 yahalomBan +*** 105 544/561 woolamce BV Secret_8 yahalompaulson +*** 106 547/561 woolamcmv BV Secret_11 yahalomBan +*** 107 547/561 woolamcmv AV Secret_8 yahalomBan +*** 108 549/561 woolamcmv BV Secret_11 yahalompaulson +*** 109 549/561 woolamcmv AV Secret_8 yahalompaulson +*** 110 557/561 yahalom AV Secret_5 yahalomBan +*** 111 560/561 yahalom AV Secret_5 yahalompaulson +Processed 561 tuple combinations in total. +Found 112 new attacks. + These were helped by: + woolampif: All-Flawed. This possibly breaks ['boyd', 'kaochow', 'kaochow2', 'kaochow3', 'wmfbrutus'] + spliceAS: All-Flawed. This possibly breaks ['nsl3', 'spliceAShcCJ'] + kaochow: All-Correct. This possibly breaks ['wmfbrutus'] + yahalomlowe: All-Correct. This possibly breaks ['denningsaccosh'] + kaochow2: All-Correct. This possibly breaks ['wmfbrutus'] + kaochow3: All-Correct. This possibly breaks ['wmfbrutus'] + nssymmetric: All-Correct. This possibly breaks ['ccitt509', 'denningsaccosh', 'ns3', 'nsl3', 'spliceAShcCJ'] + otwayrees: All-Flawed. This possibly breaks ['denningsaccosh'] + yahalomBan: All-Flawed. This possibly breaks ['boyd', 'denningsaccosh', 'kaochow', 'kaochow2', 'kaochow3', 'wmfbrutus', 'woolamce', 'woolamcmv', 'yahalom'] + wmfbrutus: All-Correct. This possibly breaks ['denningsaccosh', 'yahalomlowe'] + ksl: Mixed. This possibly breaks ['wmfbrutus'] + tmn: All-Flawed. This possibly breaks ['ccitt509', 'ns3', 'nsl3', 'spliceAShcCJ'] + spliceAShc: All-Flawed. This possibly breaks ['spliceAShcCJ'] + boyd: Mixed. This possibly breaks ['wmfbrutus'] + kaochowPalm: All-Correct. This possibly breaks ['wmfbrutus'] + gongnonce: Mixed. This possibly breaks ['kaochow', 'kaochow2', 'kaochow3', 'wmfbrutus'] + soph: All-Correct. This possibly breaks ['nsl3', 'sophkx'] + gongnonceb: Mixed. This possibly breaks ['kaochow', 'wmfbrutus'] + nsl3: All-Correct. This possibly breaks ['ns3'] + nsl7: All-Correct. This possibly breaks ['gongnonce', 'kaochow', 'ns3', 'nsl3'] + denningsaccosh: Mixed. This possibly breaks ['woolamcmv', 'yahalomlowe'] + yahalom: Mixed. This possibly breaks ['boyd', 'denningsaccosh', 'wmfbrutus', 'yahalomlowe'] + isoiec11770213: All-Correct. This possibly breaks ['denningsaccosh', 'wmfbrutus'] + woolamce: All-Correct. This possibly breaks ['boyd', 'kaochow', 'wmfbrutus'] + nssymmetricamended: All-Correct. This possibly breaks ['ccitt509', 'denningsaccosh', 'ns3', 'nsl3', 'spliceAShcCJ'] + yahalompaulson: All-Flawed. This possibly breaks ['boyd', 'denningsaccosh', 'kaochow', 'kaochow2', 'kaochow3', 'wmfbrutus', 'woolamce', 'woolamcmv', 'yahalom'] + +**************************************** + Testing tuple width 3 +**************************************** + + +**************************************** + Testing multiple match methods +**************************************** + + +**************************************** + Testing match 0 +**************************************** + +Evaluating 5984 tuples of 3 for 34 protocols. +Evaluated single results. +Correct protocols: ['ccitt509', 'kaochow', 'yahalomBan', 'yahalomlowe', 'kaochow2', 'kaochow3', 'nssymmetric', 'otwayrees', 'wmfbrutus', 'bke', 'soph', 'nsl3', 'nsl7', 'denningsaccosh', 'yahalom', 'sophkx', 'isoiec11770213', 'woolamce', 'nssymmetricamended', 'kaochowPalm', 'andrewBan'] +Partly flawed protocols: ['woolamcmv', 'andrewLoweBan', 'ksl', 'boyd', 'yahalompaulson', 'gongnonce', 'ns3', 'gongnonceb', 'spliceAShcCJ'] +Completely flawed protocols: ['spliceAS', 'woolampif', 'tmn', 'spliceAShc'] +Testing 3 tuples using --summary --match=0 --arachne --timer=4 --max-runs=4 --max-length=18 +Processed 5984 tuple combinations in total. +Found 0 new attacks. + +**************************************** + Testing match 1 +**************************************** + +Evaluating 5984 tuples of 3 for 34 protocols. +Evaluated single results. +Correct protocols: ['ccitt509', 'kaochow', 'yahalomBan', 'yahalomlowe', 'kaochow2', 'kaochow3', 'nssymmetric', 'otwayrees', 'wmfbrutus', 'bke', 'soph', 'nsl3', 'nsl7', 'denningsaccosh', 'yahalom', 'sophkx', 'isoiec11770213', 'woolamce', 'nssymmetricamended', 'kaochowPalm', 'andrewBan'] +Partly flawed protocols: ['woolamcmv', 'andrewLoweBan', 'ksl', 'boyd', 'yahalompaulson', 'gongnonce', 'ns3', 'gongnonceb', 'spliceAShcCJ'] +Completely flawed protocols: ['spliceAS', 'woolampif', 'tmn', 'spliceAShc'] +Testing 3 tuples using --summary --match=1 --arachne --timer=4 --max-runs=4 --max-length=18 +*** 0 2587/5984 denningsaccosh AV Niagree_6 nssymmetricamended yahalom +*** 1 2587/5984 denningsaccosh AV Nisynch_5 nssymmetricamended yahalom +*** 2 2686/5984 denningsaccosh AV Niagree_6 wmfbrutus yahalom +*** 3 2686/5984 denningsaccosh AV Nisynch_5 wmfbrutus yahalom +*** 4 2687/5984 woolamce BV Secret_8 denningsaccosh woolamcmv +*** 5 2697/5984 yahalom AV Secret_5 denningsaccosh woolamcmv +*** 6 2702/5984 yahalomlowe RV Niagree_13 denningsaccosh yahalomBan +*** 7 2702/5984 yahalomlowe RV Nisynch_12 denningsaccosh yahalomBan +*** 8 2702/5984 yahalomlowe RV Secret_11 denningsaccosh yahalomBan +*** 9 2704/5984 denningsaccosh AV Nisynch_5 yahalomBan yahalom +*** 10 2704/5984 denningsaccosh AV Niagree_6 yahalomBan yahalom +*** 11 2705/5984 yahalomlowe RV Niagree_13 denningsaccosh yahalompaulson +*** 12 2705/5984 yahalomlowe RV Nisynch_12 denningsaccosh yahalompaulson +*** 13 2705/5984 yahalomlowe RV Secret_11 denningsaccosh yahalompaulson +*** 14 2707/5984 denningsaccosh AV Nisynch_5 yahalompaulson yahalom +*** 15 2707/5984 denningsaccosh AV Niagree_6 yahalompaulson yahalom +*** 16 4208/5984 yahalomBan AV Secret_5 kaochow yahalompaulson +*** 17 4208/5984 yahalomBan BV Secret_6 kaochow yahalompaulson +*** 18 5019/5984 nsl7 RV Secret_4 nsl3 soph +*** 19 5021/5984 nsl7 RV Secret_5 nsl3 spliceAShc +*** 20 5022/5984 nsl7 RV Secret_5 nsl3 spliceAS +*** 21 5023/5984 nsl7 RV Secret_5 nsl3 tmn +Processed 5984 tuple combinations in total. +Found 22 new attacks. + These were helped by: + woolamcmv: Mixed. This possibly breaks ['woolamce', 'yahalom'] + nsl3: All-Correct. This possibly breaks ['nsl7'] + denningsaccosh: All-Correct. This possibly breaks ['woolamce', 'yahalom', 'yahalomlowe'] + spliceAS: All-Flawed. This possibly breaks ['nsl7'] + yahalom: All-Correct. This possibly breaks ['denningsaccosh'] + kaochow: All-Correct. This possibly breaks ['yahalomBan'] + yahalomBan: All-Correct. This possibly breaks ['yahalomlowe', 'denningsaccosh'] + spliceAShc: All-Flawed. This possibly breaks ['nsl7'] + wmfbrutus: All-Correct. This possibly breaks ['denningsaccosh'] + nssymmetricamended: All-Correct. This possibly breaks ['denningsaccosh'] + yahalompaulson: Mixed. This possibly breaks ['yahalomlowe', 'denningsaccosh', 'yahalomBan'] + soph: All-Correct. This possibly breaks ['nsl7'] + tmn: All-Flawed. This possibly breaks ['nsl7'] + +**************************************** + Testing match 2 +**************************************** + +Evaluating 5984 tuples of 3 for 34 protocols. +Evaluated single results. +Correct protocols: ['ccitt509', 'kaochow', 'yahalomlowe', 'kaochow2', 'kaochow3', 'nssymmetric', 'wmfbrutus', 'bke', 'soph', 'nsl3', 'nsl7', 'sophkx', 'isoiec11770213', 'woolamce', 'nssymmetricamended', 'kaochowPalm', 'andrewBan'] +Partly flawed protocols: ['woolamcmv', 'andrewLoweBan', 'ksl', 'boyd', 'gongnonce', 'ns3', 'gongnonceb', 'denningsaccosh', 'yahalom', 'spliceAShcCJ'] +Completely flawed protocols: ['spliceAS', 'yahalomBan', 'otwayrees', 'woolampif', 'tmn', 'spliceAShc', 'yahalompaulson'] +Testing 3 tuples using --summary --match=2 --arachne --timer=4 --max-runs=4 --max-length=18 +*** 0 450/5984 spliceAShcCJ SV Secret_8 andrewBan soph +*** 1 1309/5984 ns3 IV Niagree_i3 bke tmn +*** 2 1309/5984 ns3 IV Nisynch_i4 bke tmn +*** 3 1414/5984 soph IV Niagree_3 bke tmn +*** 4 1744/5984 ns3 IV Niagree_i3 boyd tmn +*** 5 1744/5984 ns3 IV Nisynch_i4 boyd tmn +*** 6 1849/5984 soph IV Niagree_3 boyd tmn +*** 7 2150/5984 ns3 IV Niagree_i3 ccitt509 tmn +*** 8 2150/5984 ns3 IV Nisynch_i4 ccitt509 tmn +*** 9 2255/5984 soph IV Niagree_3 ccitt509 tmn +*** 10 2437/5984 kaochow RV Secret_10 denningsaccosh nsl7 +*** 11 2528/5984 ns3 IV Niagree_i3 denningsaccosh tmn +*** 12 2528/5984 ns3 IV Nisynch_i4 denningsaccosh tmn +*** 13 2633/5984 soph IV Niagree_3 denningsaccosh tmn +*** 14 2981/5984 spliceAShcCJ SV Secret_8 gongnonceb soph +*** 15 3306/5984 spliceAShcCJ SV Secret_8 gongnonce soph +*** 16 3606/5984 spliceAShcCJ SV Secret_8 isoiec11770213 soph +*** 17 3780/5984 ns3 IV Niagree_i3 kaochowPalm tmn +*** 18 3780/5984 ns3 IV Nisynch_i4 kaochowPalm tmn +*** 19 3882/5984 spliceAShcCJ SV Secret_8 kaochowPalm soph +*** 20 4135/5984 spliceAShcCJ SV Secret_8 kaochow soph +*** 21 4210/5984 yahalomlowe RV Niagree_13 kaochow yahalompaulson +*** 22 4366/5984 spliceAShcCJ SV Secret_8 kaochow2 soph +*** 23 4441/5984 yahalomlowe RV Niagree_13 kaochow2 yahalompaulson +*** 24 4514/5984 kaochow3 IV Secret_7 nsl7 yahalomBan +*** 25 4514/5984 kaochow3 IV Niagree_6 nsl7 yahalomBan +*** 26 4514/5984 kaochow3 RV Nisynch_8 nsl7 yahalomBan +*** 27 4514/5984 kaochow3 IV Nisynch_5 nsl7 yahalomBan +*** 28 4576/5984 spliceAShcCJ SV Secret_8 kaochow3 soph +*** 29 4651/5984 yahalomlowe RV Niagree_13 kaochow3 yahalompaulson +*** 30 4886/5984 ns3 IV Niagree_i3 nssymmetricamended tmn +*** 31 4886/5984 ns3 IV Nisynch_i4 nssymmetricamended tmn +*** 32 4901/5984 ns3 IV Niagree_i3 nssymmetric tmn +*** 33 4901/5984 ns3 IV Nisynch_i4 nssymmetric tmn +*** 34 5015/5984 nsl7 RV Secret_5 nssymmetricamended nsl3 +*** 35 5016/5984 nsl7 RV Secret_5 nssymmetric nsl3 +*** 36 5349/5984 soph IV Niagree_3 nssymmetricamended tmn +*** 37 5454/5984 soph IV Niagree_3 nssymmetric tmn +Processed 5984 tuple combinations in total. +Found 38 new attacks. + These were helped by: + bke: All-Correct. This possibly breaks ['ns3', 'soph'] + spliceAS: All-Flawed. This possibly breaks ['nsl7'] + kaochow: All-Correct. This possibly breaks ['spliceAShcCJ', 'yahalomlowe'] + kaochow2: All-Correct. This possibly breaks ['spliceAShcCJ', 'yahalomlowe'] + kaochow3: All-Correct. This possibly breaks ['spliceAShcCJ', 'yahalomlowe'] + nssymmetric: All-Correct. This possibly breaks ['ns3', 'nsl7', 'soph'] + gongnonce: Mixed. This possibly breaks ['spliceAShcCJ'] + yahalomBan: All-Flawed. This possibly breaks ['kaochow3'] + tmn: All-Flawed. This possibly breaks ['ns3', 'soph', 'nsl7'] + ccitt509: All-Correct. This possibly breaks ['ns3', 'soph'] + boyd: Mixed. This possibly breaks ['ns3', 'soph'] + kaochowPalm: All-Correct. This possibly breaks ['ns3', 'spliceAShcCJ'] + spliceAShc: All-Flawed. This possibly breaks ['nsl7'] + soph: All-Correct. This possibly breaks ['spliceAShcCJ', 'nsl7'] + woolamcmv: Mixed. This possibly breaks ['yahalom'] + gongnonceb: Mixed. This possibly breaks ['spliceAShcCJ'] + nsl3: All-Correct. This possibly breaks ['nsl7'] + nsl7: All-Correct. This possibly breaks ['kaochow', 'kaochow3'] + denningsaccosh: Mixed. This possibly breaks ['kaochow', 'ns3', 'soph', 'yahalom'] + isoiec11770213: All-Correct. This possibly breaks ['spliceAShcCJ'] + nssymmetricamended: All-Correct. This possibly breaks ['ns3', 'nsl7', 'soph'] + yahalompaulson: All-Flawed. This possibly breaks ['yahalomlowe'] + andrewBan: All-Correct. This possibly breaks ['spliceAShcCJ']